Wednesday, February 20, 2019

The most dangerous law

When teaching Intro to Public Administration, or training municipal officials, I always stress that one of the greatest threats to the enlightened administration of government is “The Law of Unintended Consequences.” While resting for a few minutes recently, I flicked the TV remote and it hit the Ken Burns/ Lynn Novick documentary “The Vietnam War.”

It hit me then. I understood why I think the law I mentioned, as nebulous as it is, is so important.

What better example of history veering off the intended path can we imagine? It may not be the greatest example in our history. Intelligent and intuitive people, including Lyndon Johnson, foresaw that our military involvement in Indochina was a rocky path to follow. Politics demanded otherwise. Our involvement would defeat Communism once and for all. America would be the hero of the world. Any resisting politician was a traitor like Harry Truman, who had lost China. (Yes, losing a nation with 541 million people was quite a trick).

We struck out joyously.

What followed was failure, global humiliation, a deeply divided country, millions killed or wounded, a national cynicism, antipathy toward veterans, and more than 58,000 of their names carved into a black-granite mourning wall in Washington D.C.

I could fill pages with examples of how “The Law” has defeated good intentions. In our state, HUD decided, one year, to reward cities that would pass a stringent fair housing ordinance. What could be more proper or fitting? African Americans would benefit from inspired insight. Let us press forward. It was a another brick of good intentions paving the road to Hell.

Problem was, cities with large minority populations would not even discuss passing something as politically explosive as a fair housing ordinance with teeth. Yes, it was political cowardice, racially tinged, and untoward. Many political decisions are, unfortunately.

Cities with no minorities said, “Why the hell not? It won’t bother us.”

What happened? As we might guess, HUD money intended to help the poor, heavily represented by minorities, one year went to “Sundown Cities.”

Now we have a political independent who chooses to run for President of the United States, not as an independent, but by attaching himself to one of the two national parties. It’s his second try. His first, and indications are he was helped by a foreign enemy, resulted in the exact opposite of what his followers sought, which was a more equitable government, voter fairness, a leveling of income disparities, and love and health care for all.

Abroad, there was a Southeast Asian country once that was being overrun by a reptile species labeled in taxological terms as Ophiophagus Hannah known as the “King Cobra.” According to the late Edward C. Morgan, PhD, it is one of the most dangerous snakes in the world. While not the most poisonous, it is smart and mean, the only poisonous snake that will stalk and attack people just for the pure hell of it.

The government decided to address the problem by offering a bounty, let’s say $50.00, for each dead snake delivered.

Fine. Seemed like a good idea. It was, until the supply ran low. Then inspired villagers began breeding the things. Poor planning and inadequate enclosures produced runaways. The country ended up with more King Cobras than ever by the time officials ended the program.

Politics evades the thinking ability of zealous cult members. Ronald Reagan once said, for example, that “Facts are stupid things.” It was a slogan that apparently stuck with, and formed a chief weapon of his party, one that has stuck with his followers to this date.   

Sadly, he had intended the famous quote by John Adams, “Facts are stubborn things.”

Let us hope that President Adams, not President Reagan was right.



No comments:

Post a Comment